Linux plunge not working out so well

So I don't think Linux is ready for laptops. Well, my laptop anyway.

The first problem I encountered was with screen resolution. I didn't have an option for the "native" 1280x800 widescreen resolution of my Dell 700m. After digging through the Ubuntu support forums, I discovered that I had to install a small utility called 915resolution. It was a minor pain to track this down, as there were several contradictory sets of instructions found with Google, but running this command:
sudo apt-get install 915resolution
and restarting seemed to fix things.

My next problem was with WiFi. Ubuntu's network management applet didn't show any available wireless networks, despite the fact that I know there are dozens nearby my home. Reboot into Windows, do some more browsing, and discover some diagnostic tests to run. Boot back into Ubunutu. It appears that command-line tools can see wireless networks nearby, but Ubuntu's GUI is broken and doesn't list them. I could deal with having to run a few commands to connect, but...

It also seems that Ubuntu does not support Wifi Protected Access 2 (WPA2) wireless access points out of the box. This is a much bigger deal, as my home network is all WPA2 WiFi, and I will not "downgrade" to any version of WEP, as it is woefully insecure.

So I boot back into Windows, and do a few more hours of research. There are WPA tools for Debian-derived Linux systems, and some folks have gotten them to work. But I was really unwilling to go down this route, as the documented procedures were pages long, and involved running a command line utility to generate a password hash for each new network I wanted to use. Not exactly useful for someone who needs to do work on the go.

Finally, I looked into getting support for my Sprint Mobile Broadband Card, which provides about 1 Mbps download speed just about anywhere. This little device is my lifeline for work. From what I read on the net (again scattered over dozens of contradictory sites), there is almost no driver support at all for these mobile Wireless cards in Linux. To get something working, I would have to modify some available driver for another device and compile it into my kernel.

So I gave up. I have a family, and a job, and I just wanted to get some work done. Right now, at least, Ubuntu doesn't have enough mobile device support for my needs.

And I know all the Linux fanboys out there will call me an 1d10t n00b, and blame the hardware manufacturers for not releasing good open-source drivers. But you know what? I don't care. Ubuntu failed me. Going mobile with Windows XP is light-years easier by comparison, and I'm not going to switch to something that requires so much manual configuration each time I want to work on the road.

Maybe I'll try a MacBook instead.

Comments

zuttobenkyou said…
I've had similar experiences with Ubuntu 7.04 and WiFi on my Dell Latitude D505.

I'm currently waiting for version 8 to come out for Ubuntu this spring. It will hopefully fix some problems relating to multi-monitor support (last time I checked, Ubuntu's support for 2 LCD monitors was pretty much nonexistant).
RPM said…
zuttobenkyou, I have recently upgraded to a Dell D420, but it has the same graphics chipset, and same WiFI chipset, so I think I too will wait for Ubuntu 8. I will also try a Fedora bootable CD to see if it sees all the netowrk drivers. The lack of reasonable support for the mobile broadband cards is still a killer for me. Yes, I know this is "the vendor's fault", but as far as I can tell no U.S. mobile carrier has Linux support for their broadband cards.

Popular posts from this blog

Fixing slow NFS performance between VMware and Windows 2008 R2

Presets versus quality in x264 encoding

Google's public NTP servers?